Back to Top

International Society of Equitation Science Dublin 2008

Abstract: Overcoming hidden pain in the ridden horse: Predictable patterns of myofascial dysfunction in the equine body

Dianne Jenkins | Canberra Australia

Connective tissue damage often predisposes physiological and performance deficiencies through chronic low grade pain in the ridden horse. Even with the technological advances of ultrasonography and infrared thermography as location testing tools, assessment of these palpable issues have been inconsistent. However, learned manual assessment techniques can define the presence of these soft tissue injuries without the use of scientific equipment. This study reports on soft tissue injury record keeping over a 2 year period between Jan 2006 & Dec 2007 and reveals that 99% of 1285 horses at initial consultation, presented with myofascial distortions in one or both shoulders and all suffered varying degrees of back pain. The horses were a cross section from the thoroughbred racing, harness racing and pleasure horse industries. Several of the horses had previous veterinary treatment, but still displayed persistent unresolved pain and compromised movement. The use of innovative neurophysical release techniques during as few as three treatments over a one-month period, together with owner administrated rehabilitation exercises, usually resolved the problems completely. Palpable myofascial distortions located near the scapulo-humeral joint resolved almost all cases of back pain where the horses demonstrated inefficient movement or were out of work for long periods. Further research will determine which form of known treatment eliminates the problem in the shortest period while at the same time manual techniques are being developed and refined to facilitate these treatments. This study opens up important new avenues for dealing with health, training, behavioural and welfare issues/problems in horses. This new treatment has important implications for all involved in the horse industry from owners and riders to veterinarians, trainers and therapists because it demonstrates it is now possible to locate and address the cause of most postural inefficiencies before they, in turn, cause inevitable debilitating pathology.

 

View article in “The Irish Field”, Sat August 23rd 2008

"Dianne presenting at ISES in Dublin in 2008"

Demonstration Transcript

download here

Introduction

Today I will give a brief outline of my work that identifies an unacknowledged injury to the subcutaneous fascia, in the distal scapula region of the horse and how the altered posture adopted in compensation creates a predictable pattern of continual and chronic muscular tension and soreness.

I will demonstrate the diagnostic techniques and manipulations developed to resolve these injuries.

My work over the last 35 years indicates that this injury, this distortion of fascia, has an extremely high incident rate. 99% of all horses I work on present with 1 or both shoulders affected.

These injuries have rarely emerged as a primary condition because horses suffering with them do not present as clinically lame. There is no wound and little obvious bruising. But the horse becomes uncomfortable, offloads the leg, reduces the range of motion of the forelimb and so begins a pattern of changed behaviour and resistance that we as riders often assume is bad behaviour, not imagining the cause could be a response to pain.

The cause of this injury is incident based. I would expect to find palpable pain in the shoulder after a horse falls heavily, or has pulled off or sprung a tight shoe, has been caught up in a fence and struggled to free itself, or been cast in a stable – quite common incidents.

The injury is NOT caused by poor training methods or saddle fit.

It is most significant that this injury does NOT correct itself with rest or hard work.
ISES Dublin 2008 Dianne Jenkins Overcoming hidden pain in the ridden horse 3
Unless treated, the tissue remains distorted, causing altered posture, discomfort and pain for the horses entire life.

The earliest signs, often of sudden onset, are:

  • horses display uncharacteristic avoidance behaviours
  • not wanting to be caught, groomed or saddled
  • they become girthy and uneasy to mount
  • and then begins resistance to training,
  • inability or refusal to bend,
  • a loss of natural rhythm
  • unsteady head carriage and
  • the inability to relax the back, especially through transitions.

These are the first signs of discomfort and pain when ridden. Most riders want their horses to willingly comply, but if these difficulties are present the horse-rider relationship has already begun to deteriorate.

Let me now give you some examples of the effects of the more chronic state of this injury.

  • quiet horses lose their motivation to work,
  • they stumble for no obvious reason, and prefer to hop into canter than to lengthen their trot
  • they lose elevation within the stride,
  • are difficult to keep going, to keep on the bit and they might ‘drop out’ behind, suddenly, when ridden.
  • The spirited horse may hollow the back, try to run away, buck, or even rear.
  • The rider finds they often have to manipulate the horse’s mouth constantly to keep a rounded frame.
  • To maintain flexion, forward AND bend is very difficult.

These behaviours are clearly describing training and performance deficits.

The effect this hidden pain has on a horse’s temperament and willingness to work is what prompted me to enter the field of physical therapy.

Over the years I have resolved thousands of these injuries using the methods that I will demonstrate.

The difference this treatment makes, and quickly, to the horse’s temperament & movement, and subsequently the improvement in the relationship between the horse and rider, is undeniable.
This is why I am committed to pursuing the necessary scientific studies that will continue to prove that these injuries do exist.

Practical Assessment

I have chosen this horse for my demonstration because he is in the acute phase of this injury.

History of the horse – French race horse 6yo owned by a prominent owner of National Hunt horses. You will see he is not ‘clinically lame’. You will have noted as he was lunged in Andrew McLean’s demonstration that he could not remain quiet in side reins being lunged on the circle. He moved with some rhythm but appeared to be over fresh and did not, at any stage have a steady head carriage.

I recognize this movement and behaviour to be caused by correctable injury and restrictions in the fascial trains. I will now show you the site of the injury and the predictable pattern of compensatory issues.

I am palpating for pain responses.

These palpations are about diagnosing pain not inflicting it, so I’ll remove the pressure instantly the horse reacts with emotional resentment or because the tissue ‘guards’ against the pressure. I intend to treat the horse, so do not want him to be resentful to touch.

I invite you to watch carefully the reactions of the horse to the palpations.

If pain is experienced, expect him to flinch, suddenly raise the head, or pull away.
I will desensitise him first with firm slow strokes of effleurage along the top line of the body with even, relaxed pressure so as not to induce any reflex responses when palpating.

This is where the most common fascial distortion injury occurs – over the area where infraspinatus and supraspinatus unite. Initially, only the subcutaneous fascia is affected but myositis is detectable in the area within days.

Locate the site, then place a free hand on the other side of the scapular (not pulling on the wither spinous processes) and apply equal pressure to both sides of the horse. This counteracts the horses training to move away from pressure. Demonstration Remember, this is the acute phase. The intensity of the reactions will vary from horse to horse depending on temperament breeding and training but all reactions mean a distortion is present.

The next area to palpate is deep in what I term the wither pockets at the junction of the caudal edge of the scapular cartilage and the shelf of ribs. This is where the front of most styles of saddles rest. I would expect this area to be inflamed with 2 days of the injury occurring to the shoulder. Demonstration

We can expect this horse to be girthy and many horses will balk and rear if the rider leans forward during the acute phase of the shoulder injury even with a well-fitting saddle. My data notes that correction of the shoulder issues relieves most girth shyness.

The next area to be effected is the ‘brachiocephalic’, the lower muscle of the neck. Attached to the humerus, this muscle is over used when the shoulder injury is present. By applying pressure into the muscle tissue onto the hard lateral surface of the cervical vertebrae 4, 5 & 6 transverse processes, the horse will display a pain response indicating how sore the muscle is. Demonstration

All those tight necks you observe? Look for this shoulder injury. It is likely to be the primary cause.

The next muscles to be affected are the long back muscles and loin, Demonstration firstly on the same side as the injury, then within days the other side also.

Compensating posture causes deep and chronic contraction of these muscles. Horses often run away, hump or buck when we apply our seat aids mostly during canter transitions and half halts. So if a horse has chronic back pain, look for and correct the distorted tissue in the shoulders first.

The gluteal muscles become tight and sore on the same side, Demonstration because the horse develops a medial step under to the midline. This is firstly observed as ‘swinging leg’ where the leg swings in medially in the flight phase and deteriorates to the more serious landing on the midline as time goes on compromising the hock and stifle joints.

The hamstrings Demonstration become painful from over use when the back has lost its ability to swing. How many of you have seen a ‘lazy’ hind leg? Correct the shoulder injury on the same side. It will be there. The hind leg will regain its full use if joint damage is not present.

If the horse has continued to be worked in circles on the bit during this acute phase, it will also have severe shortening of the head oblique muscles Demonstration caused by the rider trying to encourage flexion the horse can’t relax into.

The pectorals become over tired from uneven weight distribution. Demonstration When horses suffer this injury in BOTH shoulders, many will object to traveling facing forward in the narrow space of a horse float or trailer. The continual isometric balancing is too painful in these already damaged pectoral muscles.

If the horse is kept in daily work, the foreleg flexors tighten, again in compensation, small micro tears begin to occur in the musculotendonous junctions of both the superficial and deep digital flexor muscles. If the horse resents pressure here I recommend my clients do not compete the horse for a week as under stress the soft tissue structures of the leg are at risk. Demonstration This reaction then leads me to test if there is also involvement of the suspensory apparatus or tendons. Demonstration

This system of diagnostic palpation can be learnt by vets and therapists. With the addition of red light stimulation of certain acupoints prior to palpation the responses are much easier to feel for students and those with little strength to palpate musclular horses.

It’s much easier to feel responses in the acute phase than the chronic phase when the body has laid down layers of fibrotic tissue to prevent normal stretch of the area. That takes more training in palpation and observation techniques however even owners can learn to palpate their horses to test if issues are present. If they feel their horse is not moving well, or misbehaving; all avoidance behaviours, they can include these checks to decide if the issue is pain related. They can then have a JENT professional correct the injury before further compensatory effects become apparent.

After 3-6 weeks the injury enters the chronic phase wherein the body lays down fibrotic tissue that dulls the pain of inflammation and the horse’s responses to palpation become less obvious.

Chronic issues, as in people, become ‘normalised’ and the body ceases to recognize a problem which dulls the initial pain responses to palpation.

Most horses adapt over time and adjust their stride to prevent full range of motion of the forelimb, but each horse lays down its own limits of tolerance to work, and how it interacts with other horses and people. We tend to reward horses that do not object to our training techniques and intelligent horses with less tolerance are labeled as difficult. The force and gadgetry then come out to make the horse comply.

But the performance is now chronically deficient, and never matches the movement that biomechanically the skeletal conformation should produce. A skilled rider may achieve short efforts of good movement but the horse becomes quite sore as a result.

Treatment Preparation

So, to the Treatment; I can only demonstrate an abridged version today because of our time constraints – A full treatment normally takes an hour and only one session is required to resolve a single shoulder injury in the acute phase.

Demonstration of Photonic Red Light

Bah Hui I could correct the distorted fascia straight away, manually, without any preliminaries, but it can be quite painful. Some horses are put off by that and become resentful in the future. So I always include this preparation.

Stress pt 12 in neck I am stimulating particular ‘acupoints’ to release neurochemicals that will dull pain, relax muscles and stimulate healing responses.

Bl 13×2 I used to use acupressure, but after years of stress on my hands, I changed to ‘red light’. It’s not laser or infra-red, just 5 LEDs of 660nm red light.

It’s quicker than acupressure, 10 seconds on each point is all it takes for the responses I need. And it alters the electrical potential of the skin exciting the mitochondria in the cells to accelerating division and growth so by holding the red light on any damaged area it will also stimulate healing.

LI 16 and site of shoulder fascial distortion The JENT system of treatment eliminates supposition from the equation, for example if this muscle group is just fatigued and sore from any another cause, by the time I have completed these particular acupoint stimulations, generalised muscle soreness will not be palpable.

LI 11 & 7 If, however, the tenderness presenting is one of these shoulder injuries, there will be an even more acute ‘pain’ response to the palpation – even in chronic cases. This makes it easier to assess if the area is painful due to overuse, an insult, or a distortion of the myofascia.

Bl 23×2 Although my case studies are extensive and have been meticulously kept, I also conducted a preliminary trial with the assistance of a healthily skeptical equine lameness Vet. Dr Ian Neilsen.

Bl 40 & Bl 60 The aim was firstly to prove this hidden shoulder injury commonly exists, even when owners are not aware their horse has a problem; and secondly, that after 1-2 treatments, gait changes are clearly detectable.

GB 34 & St 36 The results clearly supported both my theory of the high incident rate of these injuries, and my methods for resolving them.

Manual Corrections & Releases

I will now demonstrate the JENT release techniques I have developed to instantly release the chronic contraction in the muscles and soft tissue of the wither pockets and back, in a sequence that allows correction of the shoulder injury and the compensating issues through the fascial trains effectively with minimal discomfort to the horse.

Demonstration Wither pockets – Back x 4 – Shoulder

Rehabilitation

I wish we had more time and each of you could stand closer to observe the horse’s reactions, the relief they all clearly show immediately. Now, as I test the brachiocepahlic muscle again Demonstration you can see the pain responses have already completely gone.

After the treatment, I like to invite the horse to stretch the forelimbs so they can feel the change and the absence of pain and restriction. I do not stretch the leg; just place the hoof in a position which encourages the horse to confidently stretch the leg out through the shoulder. I find this gives each horse new confidence to move with more range of motion in the forelimbs immediately. Demonstration of closing procedure

The horse should now be walked actively in straight lines for at least 5 mins to restore and increase blood and lymphatic circulation through the affected areas.

JENT work is not a band-aid or quick fix. Most horses have had these issues for a long time and the body has set up soft tissue splints and restrictions to support the posture changes.

Unless the current treatment is for a new acute single injury, it is critical the horse is not ridden or lunged for a few days as time is required for inflammation to subside and to consolidate a change in muscle memory. However exercise IS important during those first few days. Fit horses can be maintained by led exercise in straight lines at all paces. Most need to be walked in hand daily to ensure calm and relaxed exercise and old, unfit, tired or infirm horses need a few days to rest to adjust to the changes before they are ridden again.

The shoulder fascial distortion can only reoccur with a new injury or if the correction techniques were not successful.

However, if the hooves are unbalanced, saddle is a poor fit, or there are rider balance problems, back pain may reoccur, but the shoulder fascial distortion injury will not.

There may be other primary or secondary issues or complications and damage to joints however there is added value in clearing these fascial distortions and accompanying muscular pain, as horses loosen up overall and carry their weight more evenly distributed over the four limbs. Any remaining, previously undetected issues will become acute and therefore easier for a Vet to diagnose and advise on. Any known joint problem will be eased by this treatment as the horse returns to a more balanced posture.

Conclusion

In conclusion, reflect on how many owners believe their horses are experiencing pain only to be told there is ‘no definable reason’ for the behaviour or decline in performance. Think about how many horses never reach their full potential.

These injuries are present in most horses – and further studies may now shed some light on that ‘grey’ area of subclinical lameness generally grouped as behavioural and training issues.

The fascial shoulder injuries are a primary cause of poor posture.
If left uncorrected, there will always be varying degrees of reoccurring back pain. And, eventually, joint dysfunction and diagnosable pathology.

There are implications here for all equine professionals treating movement deficiencies, as well as trainers, riders and handlers.

My life’s purpose is this work in progress. JENT aims to minimise the suffering of horses, to improve performance and well-being and to increase longevity of their working life.

The theme of this symposium is the ‘human and horse dyad’. What better time to introduce you to these discoveries about hidden pain; pain that IS all too often present and affects the temperament and tolerance of the horse to ridden work.
Today’s demonstration was intended to raise your awareness – that when horses ‘misbehave’ there may be real pain present, a real injury, even if the horse is not lame. Eliminating this pain enhances the relationship between humans and our horses.

The only way horses can tell us that there is something wrong is by not complying with what we ask of them. It is up to us to ‘listen’. Thank you for all for listening.

Question time